Hellp

I've implemented all your previous recommendations for my 900-stock news monitoring system. Now I need your expert review and guidance on verification, advanced technical analysis, and new features.

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
PART 1: VERIFICATION OF IMPLEMENTED CHANGES
═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

I've implemented the following changes based on your recommendations. Please verify if they're correct:

**1.1 Dynamic Thresholds Implementation**

```python
# config.py
def get_dynamic_thresholds(current_time, importance_level):
"""
Returns dynamic thresholds based on time of day and news importance.

importance_level:
- 0: Critical (FDA, Bankruptcy, Halt)
- 1: High (Earnings, Acquisition)
- 2: Medium (Financial news)
- 3: Low (General news)
"""
# Base thresholds by importance
base_thresholds = {
0: {'rvol': 1.5, 'volume_spike': 3.0, 'price_change': 3.0},
1: {'rvol': 2.0, 'volume_spike': 4.0, 'price_change': 4.0},
2: {'rvol': 2.5, 'volume_spike': 5.0, 'price_change': 5.0},
3: {'rvol': 3.0, 'volume_spike': 6.0, 'price_change': 6.0}
}

# Time-of-day multipliers
hour = current_time.hour
if 9 <= hour < 10: # Opening hour
multiplier = 0.8 # Lower thresholds (more sensitive)
elif 10 <= hour < 15: # Mid-day
multiplier = 1.0 # Normal thresholds
elif 15 <= hour < 16: # Closing hour
multiplier = 0.9 # Slightly lower
else: # After hours
multiplier = 1.2 # Higher thresholds (less sensitive)

thresholds = base_thresholds[importance_level]
return {
'rvol': thresholds['rvol'] * multiplier,
'volume_spike': thresholds['volume_spike'] * multiplier,
'price_change': thresholds['price_change'] * multiplier
}
```

**Q1.1:** Is this dynamic threshold logic correct? Should I adjust the multipliers or base values?

**Q1.2:** Should I add more time periods (e.g., pre-market, lunch hour)?

**1.2 Price Change Calculation**

```python
# symbol_data.py
def calculate_price_change_percent(self):
"""Calculate price change % since news time"""
if self.news_price is None or self.news_price == 0:
return 0.0

return ((self.price - self.news_price) / self.news_price) * 100
```

**Q1.3:** Is this the correct way to calculate price change? Should I use absolute value or keep the sign?

**1.3 SPY Correlation Filter**

```python
# main.py
def _check_spy_correlation(self, symbol):
"""Check if stock movement is correlated with SPY"""
if symbol not in self.spy_price_at_news:
return False

spy_change = ((self.spy_current_price - self.spy_price_at_news[symbol]) /
self.spy_price_at_news[symbol]) * 100

# If SPY change >= 0.5%, might be market-wide movement
if abs(spy_change) >= 0.5:
return True

return False
```

**Q1.4:** Is 0.5% the right threshold for SPY correlation? Should I also compare the direction (both up or both down)?

**1.4 Weekly ADV Update with RollingWindow**

```python
# symbol_data.py
class SymbolData:
def __init__(self, algo, symbol):
self.volume_window = RollingWindow[float](30) # Last 30 days

def update_daily_volume(self, volume):
"""Update rolling window with daily volume"""
self.volume_window.add(volume)

def get_average_volume(self):
"""Calculate ADV from rolling window"""
if not self.volume_window.is_ready:
return self.average_volume # Fallback to initial value

total = sum([self.volume_window[i] for i in range(self.volume_window.count)])
return total / self.volume_window.count
```

**Q1.5:** Is this the correct way to use RollingWindow for ADV? Should I update it daily or only weekly?

**1.5 AND/OR Logic for Reaction Alerts**

```python
# main.py
volume_condition = (spike_ratio >= thresholds['volume_spike'] and
rvol >= thresholds['rvol'])
price_condition = price_change >= thresholds['price_change']

# Send alert if EITHER condition is met
if volume_condition or price_condition:
send_alert()
```

**Q1.6:** Is this OR logic correct? Or should I require BOTH volume AND price for high-confidence alerts?

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
PART 2: ADVANCED TECHNICAL ANALYSIS DEVELOPMENT
═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

Currently, I'm only using RVOL and Volume Spike. I want to add more sophisticated technical analysis.

**2.1 Price Action Indicators**

**Q2.1:** What are the TOP 3 price action indicators I should add for news reaction monitoring?
- Bollinger Bands breakout?
- ATR (Average True Range)?
- Price momentum?
- Others?

**Q2.2:** How do I implement these in QuantConnect? Can you provide a code example for the most important one?

**2.2 Volume Profile Analysis**

**Q2.3:** Should I track intraday volume distribution (e.g., volume at different price levels)?

**Q2.4:** How can I detect "unusual" volume patterns beyond simple spike detection?

**2.3 Multi-Timeframe Analysis**

Currently, I only monitor 1-minute bars.

**Q2.5:** Should I also track 5-minute or 15-minute bars for confirmation?

**Q2.6:** How do I implement multi-timeframe analysis in QuantConnect without performance issues?

**2.4 Support/Resistance Levels**

**Q2.7:** Should I identify key support/resistance levels and alert when price breaks them after news?

**Q2.8:** What's the best algorithm to detect S/R levels in QuantConnect?

**2.5 Order Flow Analysis**

**Q2.9:** Can I access bid/ask data or order book depth in QuantConnect for better analysis?

**Q2.10:** If yes, how do I use it to improve reaction detection?

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
PART 3: ADVANCED FEATURES & OPTIMIZATION
═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

**3.1 Machine Learning Integration**

**Q3.1:** Can I use machine learning to predict which news will cause strong reactions?

**Q3.2:** What features should I extract (news sentiment, historical stock behavior, etc.)?

**Q3.3:** Can you recommend a simple ML model to start with in QuantConnect?

**3.2 Historical Backtesting**

**Q3.4:** How do I backtest this news monitoring system properly? Benzinga data might not be available in historical backtests.

**Q3.5:** What's the best way to evaluate the system's performance (precision, recall, false positive rate)?

**3.3 Risk Management**

**Q3.6:** Should I add position sizing recommendations based on news importance and reaction strength?

**Q3.7:** How do I calculate optimal position size considering volatility and dollar volume?

**3.4 Alert Filtering & Ranking**

**Q3.8:** Should I add a "confidence score" to each alert based on multiple factors?

**Q3.9:** What factors should contribute to this score?

**3.5 Performance Optimization**

**Q3.10:** With 900 stocks, are there any performance bottlenecks I should watch for?

**Q3.11:** Should I use `Schedule.On()` vs `on_data()` for certain operations?

**Q3.12:** Any tips for reducing memory usage?

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
PART 4: QUANTCONNECT BEST PRACTICES & FEATURES
═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

**4.1 Data Management**

**Q4.1:** What's the best way to persist data across algorithm restarts (besides ObjectStore)?

**Q4.2:** Should I use `History()` or `RollingWindow` for storing price/volume data?

**4.2 Event Scheduling**

**Q4.3:** I'm using `Schedule.On()` for weekly ADV updates. Is there a better way?

**Q4.4:** Can I schedule events based on market events (e.g., after earnings announcements)?

**4.3 Logging & Monitoring**

**Q4.5:** What's the difference between `self.log()`, `self.debug()`, and `self.error()`? When should I use each?

**Q4.6:** How do I set up custom charts/metrics in the QuantConnect dashboard?

**4.4 Live Trading Considerations**

**Q4.7:** Are there any differences in behavior between Backtest and Live Trading I should be aware of?

**Q4.8:** How do I handle algorithm restarts or disconnections in Live Trading?

**4.5 Advanced QuantConnect Features**

**Q4.9:** Can I use `Insight` objects for this type of news monitoring system?

**Q4.10:** Should I explore `Alpha Streams` for monetizing this strategy?

**Q4.11:** Can I integrate custom data sources (e.g., Twitter sentiment, Reddit mentions)?

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
PART 5: SPECIFIC IMPROVEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS
═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

Based on your deep knowledge of QuantConnect and algorithmic trading:

**Q5.1:** What are the TOP 5 improvements I should prioritize next?

**Q5.2:** Are there any QuantConnect features or APIs I'm not using that would significantly improve this system?

**Q5.3:** What are the most common mistakes traders make with news-based strategies, and how can I avoid them?

**Q5.4:** Can you suggest a "dream feature" that would take this system to the next level?

**Q5.5:** If you were building this system from scratch today, what would you do differently?

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
SUMMARY
═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════

I'm looking for:
1. ✅ Verification that my implementations are correct
2. 📈 Guidance on advanced technical analysis
3. 🚀 Ideas for new features and optimizations
4. 💡 Best practices and hidden QuantConnect features
5. 🎯 Your expert recommendations for next steps

Thank you for your continued guidance! Your previous recommendations were invaluable

The material on this website is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell, a solicitation to buy, or a recommendation or endorsement for any security or strategy, nor does it constitute an offer to provide investment advisory services by QuantConnect. In addition, the material offers no opinion with respect to the suitability of any security or specific investment. QuantConnect makes no guarantees as to the accuracy or completeness of the views expressed in the website. The views are subject to change, and may have become unreliable for various reasons, including changes in market conditions or economic circumstances. All investments involve risk, including loss of principal. You should consult with an investment professional before making any investment decisions.

Here's a full expert review and tailored guidance, integrating verification of your code, deep technical analysis direction (with code), and advanced recommendations for your 900-stock news monitoring system.

PART 1: VERIFICATION OF IMPLEMENTED CHANGES

1.1 Dynamic Thresholds Implementation

Q1.1:

Your function is sound. Multipliers are reasonable. However, opening volatility could justify an even more sensitive multiplier like 0.7 for 9:30–10:00 ET.
Adjust the base levels depending on your false positive/negative review after a few days. (e.g., if you get too many low-quality alerts, raise base values.)

Q1.2:

Yes! Add:
- Pre-market (before 9:30; multiplier 1.3–1.5).
- Lunch hour (12:00–13:00; consider 1.1: less activity, more noise).
- After-hours (after 16:00; 1.3 is fine as in your code).

1.2 Price Change Calculation

Q1.3:

Formula is correct.
Sign: Preserve the sign, as news can trigger both positive and negative moves—keep the directionality for analytics, but for some alert types (e.g., halts), you may want to use abs() on thresholds.

1.3 SPY Correlation Filter

Q1.4:

0.5% is standard, but testing 0.3% and 1.0% occasionally is sensible.
Direction check: Yes! You should compare direction: Only flag “correlated” if both SPY and your stock move in the same direction.

1.4 Weekly ADV Update with RollingWindow

Q1.5:

This is correct. RollingWindow(30) gives a 30-day window, updated daily.
Do not update only weekly; daily tracks changes in liquidity better.
Fallback to historical mean if window isn’t ready is also correct.

1.5 AND/OR Logic for Reaction Alerts

Q1.6:

Current OR logic is best for catching rare, high-impact moves. For “very high confidence”/low false positives, require BOTH with AND.
My suggestion: Use OR for main alerts, AND for “ultra-high-confidence” (trigger separate class of alert).

PART 2: ADVANCED TECHNICAL ANALYSIS DEVELOPMENT

2.1 Price Action Indicators

Q2.1: Top 3 recommendations:

(1) Bollinger Bands breakout: Volatility-adjusted price extremes are useful for news reactions.
(2) ATR-based absolute move: Combines volume spike with “exceeding x ATR” in short time.
(3) Momentum (ROC or short-term RSI): Captures acceleration after news.

Q2.2: Code Example (Bollinger Band breakout, scalable):

from AlgorithmImports import *
class SymbolData:
    def __init__(self, algo, symbol):
        self.symbol = symbol
        self.bb = algo.bb(symbol, 20, 2, Resolution.MINUTE)
        self.last_cross = None

    def is_breakout(self):
        # Check for breakout above upper band (for news reactions)
        if self.bb.is_ready:
            price = self.bb.current.value
            upper = self.bb.upper_band.current.value
            return price > upper
        return False

See subsequent section for a multi-symbol, multi-timeframe, event-driven full example.

2.2 Volume Profile Analysis

Q2.3:

Intraday volume profile is advanced but helpful (watch for block trades or distribution above/below news price). It’s heavy for 900 stocks unless you track only top news movers.

Q2.4:

Detect “unusual” patterns by comparing intraday volume (per bar, per price) to a rolling intraday profile (e.g., spike in first 10-min volume relative to average first-10-min).

2.3 Multi-Timeframe Analysis

Q2.5:

Yes, absolutely. Use 5- and 15-min bars for secondary confirmation. Example: require 1-min AND 5-min breakouts for “super” alerts.

Q2.6: Implementation advice:

Use TradeBarConsolidator for each needed timeframe; feed indicators only on their respective data. See detailed code below.

2.4 Support/Resistance Levels

Q2.7:

Adding S/R breaks after news is valuable: these often trigger further momentum.

Q2.8:

Simple algorithms: Rolling pivot highs/lows, or clustering of recent highs/lows. More advanced: use Z-score of clusters.
QuantConnect doesn’t have a built-in, so implement with a RollingWindow on 20- or 50-bar highs/lows.

2.5 Order Flow Analysis

Q2.9:

Bid/ask available for some assets/periods (mostly US equities in live). Order book depth (Level 2) is not standard on QuantConnect.

Q2.10:

If you have bid/ask: track spread tightening, aggressive lifting/hitting after news for extra confirmation.

PART 2: CODE SNIPPET—SCALABLE TECHNICAL-EVENT MONITORING AND MULTI-TIMEFRAME

from AlgorithmImports import *
class SymbolData:
    """Per-symbol indicators: scalable, event-driven example"""
    def __init__(self, algo, symbol):
        self.symbol = symbol
        # 1-min BB for instant reaction
        self.bb_1m = BollingerBands(20, 2)
        c_1 = TradeBarConsolidator(timedelta(minutes=1))
        c_1.data_consolidated += lambda s, bar: self.bb_1m.update(bar.end_time, bar.close)
        algo.subscription_manager.add_consolidator(symbol, c_1)
        self.c_1 = c_1

        # 5-min BB for confirmation
        self.bb_5m = BollingerBands(20, 2)
        c_5 = TradeBarConsolidator(timedelta(minutes=5))
        c_5.data_consolidated += lambda s, bar: self.bb_5m.update(bar.end_time, bar.close)
        algo.subscription_manager.add_consolidator(symbol, c_5)
        self.c_5 = c_5

    def is_breakout(self):
        return self.bb_1m.is_ready and self.bb_1m.current.value > self.bb_1m.upper_band.current.value

    def is_breakout_multi(self):
        return (self.bb_1m.is_ready and self.bb_5m.is_ready and
                self.bb_1m.current.value > self.bb_1m.upper_band.current.value and
                self.bb_5m.current.value > self.bb_5m.upper_band.current.value)

Practices:

Only update indicators on new consolidated bars (not every OnData call).
No loops in OnData (scales linearly).
Remove/detach consolidators when symbol is removed.

PART 3: ADVANCED FEATURES & OPTIMIZATION

3.1 Machine Learning Integration

Q3.1-3:

Yes, you can use scikit-learn (backtest) or LightGBM (production) models offline, import model and use in QC.
Features: news sentiment, historical move distribution, time of day, volume spikes, relative intraday moves.
Simple: Start with logistic regression or random forest. QuantConnect supports this (but train/test externally for news data).

3.2 Historical Backtesting

Q3.4-3.5:

News data is only available live/forward. For backtest: simulate with earning dates, press release times, or synthetic events.
For evaluation: save detection rate (true/false positives), average move post-alert, latency, and side (direction).

3.3 Risk Management

Q3.6-3.7:

Size positions by: (a) dollar-volume × volatility (ATR), (b) news importance, (c) confidence score.

3.4 Alert Filtering & Ranking

Q3.8-3.9:

Add confidence score using: indicator strength, news importance, time-of-day, liquidity, pre/post market, history of symbol reactions.

3.5 Performance Optimization

Q3.10:

Main bottlenecks: loops in OnData, high-frequency indicator updates, storing large history for 900 stocks.
Use event-driven pattern, RollingWindow, summary stats only, and consolidate to reduce pressure.

Q3.11:

Schedule.On() is best for daily/weekly/trade window tasks. OnData for event-driven tick/minute actions.

Q3.12:

Reduce memory: avoid large lists, use RollingWindow, clean up unused objects, flag for gc.

PART 4: QUANTCONNECT BEST PRACTICES & FEATURES

Q4.1:

Besides ObjectStore: for backtests, store in context; for live, push to S3/SQL/firestore if needed.

Q4.2:

RollingWindow for in-memory streaming, History() for cold boot/histogramming.
- Mix: Use RollingWindow for recent data, refresh with History() at startup or recovery.

Q4.3-4:

Schedule.On() is best for time-based, but for “event-based” (like earnings): use custom event detectors and schedule from a calendar or watch for events in OnData/news feed.

Q4.5:

self.log(): Always logs (Info, persistent in logs),
self.debug(): Debug, visible during debugging (but not always in final logs),
self.error(): Errors only—use for catching bugs/fails.

Q4.6:

Custom charts: see docs and above for Chart and Series. Build in Initialize, plot in any handler.

Q4.7-4.8:

Live = possible data gaps (due to reconnects), partial fills, slippage, rate limits.
On restart/disconnect: rebuild state from ObjectStore/history where needed, resume subscriptions, be conservative in order issuing (avoid double orders or position flip-flops).

Q4.9:

You can use Insight to signal predicted moves, quantifying direction/magnitude/confidence (integrates with backtests, Alpha Streams).

Q4.10:

Yes, Alpha Streams can monetize predictive signals, but it requires you to formalize signals as Insight.

Q4.11:

Yes! You can use custom data sources, including Twitter/Reddit feeds.

PART 5: SPECIFIC IMPROVEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS

Q5.1: TOP 5 next priorities

Add multi-timeframe confirmation (see above).
Add S/R breakout detection after news.
Build and tune a confidence scoring/ranking system.
Implement memory and state management to guarantee scalability to 900+ stocks.
Set up systematic logging, KPI dashboards, and robust alert monitoring.

Q5.2:

Not yet using: Insight objects, custom charting/metric dashboards, Alpha Streams integration, or persistent custom data/sentiment.

Q5.3:

Overfitting thresholds, skipping directionality, ignoring liquidity (alerts on illiquid names), not clearing memory on symbol removal, unrealistic backtests (no news in history).

Q5.4: Dream Feature:

Real-time sentiment analysis (Twitter/Reddit/API), anomaly detection (auto-tuning thresholds intra-day), or integrating full L1 order flow for “tape reading” style alerts.

Q5.5:

Build modular: Universe selection → Per-symbol detector class → Event handlers (OnData, OnSymbolEvent, etc). Design for scale and persistency from start.

SUMMARY

✅ Your verification items are well-executed; minor improvements recommended.
📈 Focus next on robust, event-driven, multi-timeframe technical analysis, especially Bollinger breakout, ATR, and S/R after news.
🚀 Implement confidence ranking, optimize memory/performance, and lay foundation for ML and persistent state.
💡 Leverage QuantConnect “hidden gems”: custom dashboards, Insight/AlphaStreams, and multi-source event input.
🎯 Modularize and document, using advanced event scheduling, indicator structure, and scalable RollingWindow storage as above.

Sample code for scalable event-driven multi-timeframe indicator logic: (see previous code output). This structure underpins robust, high-frequency news/technical monitoring over hundreds of stocks.

Let me know which specific next improvement to build out or integrate first, or ask for code for any advanced item above!

Sources: Key Concepts - QuantConnect.com, Algorithm Engine - QuantConnect.com, Overview - QuantConnect.com, Empty Equity And Options400 Benchmark, Research Guide - QuantConnect.com

SIGN IN

Radically Open-Source Algorithmic Trading Engine

Join Our Discord Channel

Draft Discussions

Bookmarked Discussions

SEARCH DISCUSSIONS

TOP 5 Research Publications

444,200 Quants.

VOTE FOR UPCOMING FEATURES

Hellp

PART 1: VERIFICATION OF IMPLEMENTED CHANGES

1.1 Dynamic Thresholds Implementation

1.2 Price Change Calculation

1.3 SPY Correlation Filter

1.4 Weekly ADV Update with RollingWindow

1.5 AND/OR Logic for Reaction Alerts

PART 2: ADVANCED TECHNICAL ANALYSIS DEVELOPMENT

2.1 Price Action Indicators

2.2 Volume Profile Analysis

2.3 Multi-Timeframe Analysis

2.4 Support/Resistance Levels

2.5 Order Flow Analysis

PART 2: CODE SNIPPET—SCALABLE TECHNICAL-EVENT MONITORING AND MULTI-TIMEFRAME

PART 3: ADVANCED FEATURES & OPTIMIZATION

3.1 Machine Learning Integration

3.2 Historical Backtesting

3.3 Risk Management

3.4 Alert Filtering & Ranking

3.5 Performance Optimization

PART 4: QUANTCONNECT BEST PRACTICES & FEATURES

PART 5: SPECIFIC IMPROVEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS

SUMMARY

Allocate to this Strategy

Organization

Team

Clone Strategy

Previous Ranking

IN THIS RESEARCH

PARTICIPANTS

Discussion Awards

SHARE RESEARCH

SHARE DISCUSSION

SHARE ARTICLE

SHARE

Actions

Join QuantConnect for Free