@Mia Alissi
I've completed Phase 1 of the critical improvements you recommended. I'd like your review to ensure everything is implemented correctly before moving to Phase 2.
## Phase 1 Improvements Summary:
### 1. Enhanced SPY Filter (Same Direction Check)
I updated `_check_spy_correlation()` to include direction checking:
```python
# Calculate SPY change since news time
spy_change = ((self.spy_current_price - self.spy_price_at_news[symbol]) /
self.spy_price_at_news[symbol]) * 100
# Calculate stock change since news time
stock_change = self.symbol_data_dict[symbol].calculate_price_change_percent()
# Check for large SPY movement (>= 0.5%)
if abs(spy_change) >= 0.5:
# NEW V5.1: Check for same direction
same_direction = (spy_change > 0 and stock_change > 0) or \
(spy_change < 0 and stock_change < 0)
if same_direction:
# Correlated with market - ignore alert
return True
else:
# Different directions - stock moving independently
return False
```
**Questions:**
1. Is this the correct way to implement "same direction" checking?
2. Should I use absolute values for comparison, or is the current approach correct?
3. Is 0.5% the right threshold for SPY movement, or should it be adjusted?
4. Should I add a minimum stock movement threshold (e.g., ignore if stock moved <1%)?
---
### 2. Updated Dynamic Thresholds (Time Periods)
I updated `TIME_OF_DAY_MULTIPLIERS` in config.py and added `get_time_of_day_period()` in helpers.py:
```python
TIME_OF_DAY_MULTIPLIERS = {
'pre_market': 0.8, # NEW: 04:00-09:30
'opening': 0.7, # UPDATED: was 1.0, now 0.7 (more sensitive)
'lunch': 1.2, # NEW: 12:00-14:00 (less sensitive)
'mid_day': 1.0, # 10:00-15:00
'closing': 0.9 # 15:00-16:00
}
def get_time_of_day_period(time):
"""Determine time period for dynamic thresholds"""
hour = time.hour
minute = time.minute
if hour < 9 or (hour == 9 and minute < 30):
return 'pre_market'
elif hour == 9 and minute >= 30 or hour < 10:
return 'opening'
elif 12 <= hour < 14:
return 'lunch'
elif 15 <= hour < 16:
return 'closing'
else:
return 'mid_day'
```
**Questions:**
5. Are these time periods correctly defined for US market hours?
6. Are the multipliers (0.7 for opening, 1.2 for lunch) appropriate?
7. Should I add more granular periods (e.g., "power hour" 15:30-16:00)?
8. Is the logic in `get_time_of_day_period()` correct?
---
### 3. Added Ultra-High-Confidence Category
I added a new confidence level that uses AND logic instead of OR:
```python
def _check_ultra_high_confidence(self, symbol, thresholds):
"""
Check for Ultra-High-Confidence criteria
Uses AND logic: ALL conditions must be met
"""
data = self.symbol_data_dict[symbol]
volume_spike_threshold, rvol_threshold, price_change_threshold = thresholds
# Calculate indicators
has_spike, spike_ratio = data.check_volume_spike()
rvol = data.current_rvol
price_change = abs(data.calculate_price_change_percent())
# AND logic: ALL conditions must be met
volume_condition = has_spike and spike_ratio >= volume_spike_threshold
rvol_condition = rvol >= rvol_threshold
price_condition = price_change >= price_change_threshold
is_ultra_high = volume_condition and rvol_condition and price_condition
return is_ultra_high
```
And updated `_check_reaction_alert()` to check Ultra-High-Confidence first:
```python
# Check Ultra-High-Confidence first
is_ultra_high = self._check_ultra_high_confidence(symbol, thresholds)
if is_ultra_high:
# Send Ultra-High-Confidence alert with "critical" priority
msg = self.notifier.build_ultra_high_confidence_alert(...)
self.notifier.queue_alert(msg, priority="critical")
return
# Otherwise, use regular AND/OR logic
volume_condition = (has_spike and spike_ratio >= volume_spike_threshold and
rvol >= rvol_threshold)
price_condition = abs(price_change) >= price_change_threshold
if not (volume_condition or price_condition):
return
```
**Questions:**
9. Is this the correct implementation of Ultra-High-Confidence (AND logic)?
10. Should I check Ultra-High-Confidence BEFORE or AFTER SPY filter?
11. Is "critical" the right priority level for Ultra-High-Confidence alerts?
12. Should I use `abs(price_change)` or just `price_change` in the condition?
13. Is the flow correct: Ultra-High → Critical, else Regular → High/Normal?
---
### 4. Telegram Alert Message
I added `build_ultra_high_confidence_alert()` with a distinctive format:
```python
message = f"""🔥🔥🔥 <b>ULTRA HIGH CONFIDENCE</b> 🔥🔥🔥
===================================
{emoji} <b>All indicators confirmed!</b>
📊 Stock: <code>{symbol.value}</code>
💵 Price: <code>${symbol_data.price:.2f}</code>
Technical Analysis:
📈 Volume Spike: <code>{spike_ratio:.1f}x</code> ✅
📊 RVOL: <code>{rvol:.2f}</code> ✅
💹 Price Change: <code>{price_change:+.2f}%</code> ✅
🎯 <b>High-confidence opportunity - strong reaction to news!</b>
"""
```
**Questions:**
14. Is this message format clear and actionable?
15. Should I add any additional information (e.g., expected move, risk level)?
---
## Overall Questions:
16. Did I implement all 3 critical improvements correctly?
17. Are there any edge cases I should handle?
18. Should I add any logging or debugging statements?
19. Is the order of operations correct in `_check_reaction_alert()`?
20. Are there any performance concerns with these changes?
---
## Next Steps:
After your review, I'll move to **Phase 2: Advanced Indicators** (Bollinger Bands, ATR, ROC, Multi-Timeframe).
Thank you for your guidance
Mia Alissi
Here is a comprehensive review of your Phase 1 improvements. Please see the detailed point-by-point feedback below before proceeding to Phase 2:
SECTION 1 – Enhanced SPY Filter
Same-direction logic:
Your sign-checking logic:
is correct for basic direction correlation.
Edge cases to consider:
spy_change == 0orstock_change == 0, direction is ambiguous — you may want to skip the correlation test in these cases to avoid bias.Absolute Values vs. Directional:
abs()when assessing if a price move is significant (so both +1% and -1% trigger the threshold).SPY 0.5% Threshold:
Stock minimum movement:
SECTION 2 – Dynamic Time-of-Day Thresholds
Time periods and US market alignment:
Example improved breakdown:
Multiplier values:
Logic validation:
<and>=to prevent overlaps or gaps.SECTION 3 – Ultra-High-Confidence Category
abs(price_change)for both AND and regular checks. This ensures large negative moves trigger just like positive ones.return(to prevent duplicate alerts).SECTION 4 – Telegram Alert Message
Keep brevity; avoid clutter, especially since this priority is for only the highest-quality signals.
OVERALL REVIEW & ADDITIONAL RECOMMENDATIONS
Implementation:
Edge Cases:
Logging/Debugging:
Order of Operations:
return→ (SPY filter then Regular alerts): Correct and robust.Performance:
General Defensive Spots:
timedelta.total_seconds()for interval math rather than manual component checks.Summary
Your Phase 1 upgrade is on solid ground! You handled all three areas correctly and laid a robust foundation. Implement the defensive protections and logging as above. You’re ready to proceed to Phase 2 once those are in place.
Let me know when you want to begin integrating advanced indicators (Bollinger Bands, ATR, ROC, MTF)!
The material on this website is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell, a solicitation to buy, or a recommendation or endorsement for any security or strategy, nor does it constitute an offer to provide investment advisory services by QuantConnect. In addition, the material offers no opinion with respect to the suitability of any security or specific investment. QuantConnect makes no guarantees as to the accuracy or completeness of the views expressed in the website. The views are subject to change, and may have become unreliable for various reasons, including changes in market conditions or economic circumstances. All investments involve risk, including loss of principal. You should consult with an investment professional before making any investment decisions.
مطلق الشمري
The material on this website is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell, a solicitation to buy, or a recommendation or endorsement for any security or strategy, nor does it constitute an offer to provide investment advisory services by QuantConnect. In addition, the material offers no opinion with respect to the suitability of any security or specific investment. QuantConnect makes no guarantees as to the accuracy or completeness of the views expressed in the website. The views are subject to change, and may have become unreliable for various reasons, including changes in market conditions or economic circumstances. All investments involve risk, including loss of principal. You should consult with an investment professional before making any investment decisions.
To unlock posting to the community forums please complete at least 30% of Boot Camp.
You can continue your Boot Camp training progress from the terminal. We hope to see you in the community soon!