Help mia

# QuantConnect Support Questions - Benzinga News Feed Implementation

## Project Context

We are developing a professional news monitoring algorithm for the Almuraqib financial AI project, targeting approximately 700-900 low-float stocks with real-time news alerts via Telegram.

## Current Implementation Overview

### Functions Used:

1. **`OnSecuritiesChanged(self, changes)`** - Called when securities are added/removed from universe

2. **`AddData(BenzingaNews, symbol)`** - Subscribe to Benzinga news for a specific symbol

3. **`RemoveData(BenzingaNews, symbol)`** - Unsubscribe from news for a symbol

4. **`OnData(self, data)`** - Receives news articles through `data.Get(BenzingaNews)`

5. **`self.notify.telegram(id, message, token)`** - Send Telegram notifications

### Current Workflow:

```python

def OnSecuritiesChanged(self, changes):

for security in changes.AddedSecurities:

symbol = security.Symbol

if symbol.value in self.universe_tickers:

self.AddData(BenzingaNews, symbol)

self.news_subscriptions.add(symbol.value)

self.log(f"[News] Added news subscription for {symbol.value}")

for security in changes.RemovedSecurities:

symbol = security.Symbol

if symbol.value in self.news_subscriptions:

self.RemoveData(BenzingaNews, symbol)

self.news_subscriptions.discard(symbol.value)

```

### Data Received:

```python

def OnData(self, data):

if data.ContainsKey(BenzingaNews):

news_collection = data.Get(BenzingaNews)

for article in news_collection.Values:

# Article contains: Title, Contents, Symbols, Categories, Tags, etc.

self.process_news_article(article)

```

---

## Questions for QuantConnect Support

### 1. News Subscription Verification

**Q1.1:** When we call `self.AddData(BenzingaNews, symbol)` for a stock, is there any callback, event, or confirmation mechanism that tells us:

- The subscription was successfully created?

- The subscription is actively receiving data?

- The subscription failed or encountered an error?

**Q1.2:** How can we programmatically verify that all our news subscriptions (700+ stocks) are active and working? Currently, we track subscriptions manually using a set (`self.news_subscriptions`), but we have no platform-level confirmation.

**Q1.3:** Does Benzinga News Feed provide any subscription status API or method we can query? For example:

```python

# Does something like this exist?

subscription_status = self.GetDataStatus(BenzingaNews, symbol)

active_subscriptions = self.GetActiveSubscriptions(BenzingaNews)

```

**Q1.4:** In `OnData(data)`, if we don't receive news for a particular stock for several days, does that mean:

- A) The subscription is working, but there's no news for that stock

- B) The subscription might have failed

- C) There's no way to distinguish between these cases

**Q1.5:** Are there any logs or diagnostics we can enable to see all active Benzinga subscriptions at runtime?

---

### 2. News Data Coverage and Limitations

**Q2.1:** When we subscribe to 700-900 stocks simultaneously for Benzinga News:

- Is there a maximum limit on concurrent subscriptions?

- Are there rate limits or throttling we should be aware of?

- Could some subscriptions fail silently if we exceed limits?

**Q2.2:** The Benzinga News Feed documentation mentions "8,000 Equities" coverage. Does this mean:

- Any US equity can have a successful subscription?

- Or only 8,000 specific equities have news coverage, and others won't receive data?

**Q2.3:** If we subscribe to a stock that Benzinga doesn't cover, what happens?

- Does `AddData()` fail with an error?

- Does it succeed but never trigger `OnData()`?

- Is there a way to check coverage before subscribing?

---

### 3. Translation and Internationalization

**Q3.1:** Does QuantConnect provide any built-in translation capabilities for news article content? Specifically:

- Can we translate `article.title` and `article.contents` to other languages (e.g., Arabic)?

- Are there any integrated translation APIs or libraries available in the cloud environment?

**Q3.2:** What Python libraries are available in the QuantConnect environment for text translation?

- Google Translate API (googletrans)?

- Deep Translator?

- Other translation libraries?

**Q3.3:** If external translation services are required, what's the recommended approach:

- Call external APIs from within the algorithm (e.g., Google Cloud Translation API)?

- Pre-process translations outside QuantConnect?

- Use a separate microservice that receives Telegram messages and translates them?

**Q3.4:** Are there any latency or networking restrictions when calling external APIs from within a live algorithm?

---

### 4. Telegram Integration Best Practices

**Q4.1:** Our current implementation uses:

```python

self.notify.telegram(

id=self.TELEGRAM_CHAT_ID,

message=message,

token=self.TELEGRAM_BOT_TOKEN

)

```

Is this the correct and most reliable way to send Telegram messages? We previously had issues with parameter ordering.

**Q4.2:** Are there any message size limits for `notify.telegram()`? Our news alerts can be quite long with metadata.

**Q4.3:** When sending many Telegram messages in rapid succession (multiple news articles arriving simultaneously), are there:

- Rate limits we should respect?

- Recommended batching strategies?

- Risk of messages being dropped or delayed?

**Q4.4:** Is there a way to verify if a Telegram message was successfully delivered, or do we rely on the return value of `notify.telegram()`?

---

### 5. BenzingaNews Object Structure

**Q5.1:** What is the complete list of attributes available on a `BenzingaNews` article object? Documentation shows:

- `title`, `contents`, `symbols`, `categories`, `tags`, `author`, `created_at`, `updated_at`

Are there other attributes we should be aware of? For example:

- Article ID or unique identifier?

- Importance/priority score?

- Related stocks beyond the primary symbol?

- Sentiment indicators?

**Q5.2:** The `article.symbols` attribute - does this return:

- A list of ticker strings (e.g., `["AAPL", "MSFT"]`)?

- A list of Symbol objects?

- What's the exact data type?

**Q5.3:** Are `article.categories` and `article.tags` standardized lists we can rely on for classification? For example:

- Will FDA-related news consistently have "FDA" in categories or tags?

- Are there official category/tag enumerations we can reference?

---

### 6. Current Implementation Review

**Q6.1:** Based on our implementation above, are we following QuantConnect best practices for:

- News subscription management?

- Handling large numbers of subscriptions (700+ stocks)?

- Processing news articles efficiently?

**Q6.2:** We currently use:

- `OnSecuritiesChanged()` to add/remove news subscriptions

- Manual tracking with `self.news_subscriptions` set

- `OnData()` to process incoming news

Is this the recommended pattern, or is there a more efficient/reliable approach?

**Q6.3:** We're tracking subscriptions in a Python set:

```python

self.news_subscriptions = set() # Set of ticker strings

```

Should we be tracking Symbol objects instead of ticker strings for better reliability?

**Q6.4:** For a live trading algorithm monitoring 700-900 stocks, are there any memory or performance considerations we should be aware of when using Benzinga News Feed?

---

### 7. Error Handling and Reliability

**Q7.1:** If the Benzinga News Feed service experiences downtime or connectivity issues:

- Will `OnData()` stop being called?

- Will we receive any error notifications?

- How should we detect and handle such scenarios?

**Q7.2:** What happens if we miss news articles due to:

- Algorithm restart?

- Platform maintenance?

- Network issues?

Is there a way to query historical news that we might have missed (within reasonable time limits)?

**Q7.3:** Are there any health check or heartbeat mechanisms we can implement to ensure our news monitoring is functioning correctly?

---

### 8. Testing and Debugging

**Q8.1:** In backtesting mode, does `notify.telegram()` work, or is it only available in live/paper trading?

**Q8.2:** How can we test our news monitoring logic without waiting for real news to arrive? Is there a way to:

- Simulate news articles?

- Replay historical news data?

- Trigger test news events?

**Q8.3:** What's the best way to debug why certain news articles might not be received? Are there verbose logging options for data subscriptions?

---

## Summary

We want to ensure our implementation is:

1. ✅ **Reliable** - All 700+ stocks are actually monitored

2. ✅ **Verifiable** - We can confirm subscriptions are active

3. ✅ **Scalable** - No hidden limits or performance issues

4. ✅ **Maintainable** - Following QuantConnect best practices

5. ✅ **International** - Ideally with translation capabilities

Any guidance on these questions would be greatly appreciated to help us build a robust, production-ready news monitoring system.

---

**Algorithm Details:**

- Platform: QuantConnect Cloud

- Language: Python

- Data Source: Benzinga News Feed

- Target: 700-900 US equities (low-float stocks)

- Notification: Telegram via `notify.telegram()`

- Mode: Live/Paper Trading

The material on this website is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell, a solicitation to buy, or a recommendation or endorsement for any security or strategy, nor does it constitute an offer to provide investment advisory services by QuantConnect. In addition, the material offers no opinion with respect to the suitability of any security or specific investment. QuantConnect makes no guarantees as to the accuracy or completeness of the views expressed in the website. The views are subject to change, and may have become unreliable for various reasons, including changes in market conditions or economic circumstances. All investments involve risk, including loss of principal. You should consult with an investment professional before making any investment decisions.

Here's a detailed, QuantConnect-fluent response to your comprehensive Benzinga News Feed implementation queries. For each section, relevant best practices, limitations, diagnostics, and technical details are provided according to the latest (2024) QuantConnect documentation and platform behavior:

1. News Subscription Verification

Q1.1 – Q1.3: Subscription Confirmation, Verification, and Status APIs

AddData(BenzingaNews, symbol) does not provide any explicit callback, confirmation, or event indicating the subscription's success or health. The API is synchronous and will only error for immediate parameter problems.
There is no built-in function like GetDataStatus() or GetActiveSubscriptions() for programmatically verifying data subscription health or listing active dataset subscriptions at runtime (source).
The only way to programmatically confirm a subscription is working is if you:
1. See the symbol processed in OnData() (i.e., actually receive news articles).
2. Request historical data for the Benzinga symbol — if history returns results, the feed is working and covered.
Silent failure: If you subscribe to a ticker for which Benzinga never delivers news, you will receive no error; OnData() will simply never be called for that symbol.

Q1.4: News Silence

Not receiving news for days for a ticker most likely means there’s genuinely no article from Benzinga for it, especially for minor stocks. This is normal and not an error.
There is no way to distinguish between “no news” and “subscription failure” at the platform level for properly formed subscriptions.

Q1.5: Logs/Diagnostics

There is no runtime log or dashboard within QuantConnect Cloud that shows a live list of dataset subscriptions or their health.
Recommended practice: Log every AddData()/RemoveData() event yourself and periodically request history to validate liveness.

2. News Data Coverage and Limitations

Q2.1: Maximum Subscriptions, Rate Limits

No explicit, documented hard limit for concurrent Benzinga subscriptions is stated, but QuantConnect’s RAM and CPU quotas apply. Algorithms with >1000 subscriptions may hit performance or stability issues, especially in live mode.
No Benzinga-specific API or rate throttling is described; but, as with all cloud-hosted code, try to keep resource usage moderate to avoid runtime throttling.

Q2.2: Benzinga Dataset Coverage

Coverage claims “about 8,000 US equities.” This refers to Benzinga’s editorial scope. Subscribing to others (“OTC”, “foreign”, etc.) won’t raise an error, but you’ll never receive articles for them.

Q2.3: What Happens on Uncovered Stock?

AddData() will succeed syntactically.
OnData() will never fire for that symbol.
There is no pre-check available for coverage; you must test with historical data or check Benzinga’s official documentation for covered tickers.

3. Translation and Internationalization

Q3.1–Q3.2: Built-In and Available Translation Methods

QuantConnect does not provide any built-in translation APIs for news datasets (including Benzinga).
No sanctioned Python translation packages (e.g., googletrans, deep-translator) are preinstalled in the research or live environments.
You cannot install arbitrary Python libraries in managed cloud algorithms.

Q3.3–Q3.4: External APIs, Networking/Latency

You may access external APIs if your algorithm’s network permissions allow it (check the API whitelist).
Since each external API call introduces latency and may cause rate limits, the recommended pattern is:
- For critical/production systems, process translation in a separate microservice (message relay or webhook) outside QuantConnect (on Google/AWS/Azure). Your algo sends concise, raw message → relay translates and sends to Telegram.
- Directly calling Google Cloud Translation or similar APIs from inside your algo is discouraged due to unknown network reliability in live trading.
- Pre-processing translations offline (before trading) is also an option for static datasets.

4. Telegram Integration Best Practices

Q4.1 – Q4.4

The correct signature is:

self.notify.telegram(id=CHAT_ID, message=message, token=BOT_TOKEN)

Usage of explicit parameter names is encouraged (do not rely on positional order).
Message size: Telegram’s official API caps messages at 4096 UTF-8 characters. If you exceed that, your message will be truncated or rejected.
Rate limits: Telegram bots can send ~30 messages per second, but QuantConnect may impose lower send-rate quotas (to avoid abuse). Exceeding this may drop or delay messages.
Batching: If news is high-frequency, batch messages before sending, or queue them to control rate.
Delivery confirmation: notify.telegram() returns a boolean (or nothing); there is no per-message delivery ack/receipt. For guaranteed delivery, relay the message to an outbound microservice and use Telegram’s official API with status checks.

5. BenzingaNews Object Structure

Q5.1: Attributes

The object provides:

id (unique article ID, integer)
title
author
created_at and updated_at (datetimes)
teaser
contents
categories (list[str])
symbols (list[str], i.e., tickers)
[NO priority/importance/sentiment by default. You must analyze/interpolate from text.]
[NO “primary symbol” or related stocks differentiation: symbols are the tickers mentioned.]

Q5.2: `symbols` Attribute Type

The symbols property returns a list of strings (media tickers), not Symbol objects. (["AAPL", "MSFT"] etc).

Q5.3: Categories/Tags Standardization

Categories and tags are editorially assigned and may vary. There’s no published standard list or enumeration. Major themes (e.g., “FDA”) may be consistently tagged, but you should analyze your dataset for consistency.
It is possible for “FDA” news to be tagged inconsistently or missing tags.

6. Implementation Review

Q6.1–Q6.2: Patterns

Your subscription, removal, and manual tracking logic is standard for QuantConnect professionals.
There’s no set-and-forget; all tracking (for reliability) is up to you.

Q6.3: Set of Strings vs. Symbol Objects

If you ever use Symbol mapping (e.g., rev splits, symbol changes), it is best practice to track subscriptions by Symbol object, NOT strings. This preserves accuracy as tickers change.

Q6.4: Large Subscription Scaling Concerns

Live algorithms with 700–900 subscriptions may push memory usage (especially in second-resolution mode), which can risk throttling or out-of-memory kills.
Monitor algorithm logs and performance statistics; consider partitioning strategies if necessary.

7. Error Handling and Reliability

Q7.1: Data Feed Failures/Downtime

If the dataset source (Benzinga) or the QuantConnect data bridge goes down: OnData() will stop being called for all affected symbols. There is no explicit error notification.
You must implement a heartbeat – monitor expected event frequency, and self-log or alert if expected news/event horizon is exceeded without any data.

Q7.2: Missed News (Restarts, Maintenance)

Missed news cannot be automatically recovered after an algo restart.
However, you can issue a self.history(BenzingaNews, symbol, lookback, Resolution.MINUTE) request to try to “catch up” on missed news articles.
There is no guarantee you will receive immediate backfill if the gap is large or not covered.

Q7.3: Health Check/Heartbeat

Periodically poll history for each symbol.
Maintain last received article timestamp per symbol, and alert if none has arrived in X expected window.

8. Testing and Debugging

Q8.1: Telegram/Backtesting

notify.telegram() is not active in backtesting. Backtest runs will simply “no-op” (do nothing) for these calls—use self.Debug() instead.

Q8.2: Simulating/Test News Articles

The best way to test news-handling logic is through backtest over historical dates with real Benzinga news present, or by retrieving historical data via self.history.
There is no official tool to inject/simulate fake news in live mode.

Q8.3: Debugging Missing Articles, Diagnostics

Use extensive in-code logging (self.Debug) for every AddData(), RemoveData(), and OnData() event.
QuantConnect docs mention no official verbose logging for news/subscription at the data feed level. However, failed history queries or total absence of a symbol in received data is a signal of coverage/subscription issues.

Summary Checklist for Production Readiness

✅ Subscribe with AddData(BenzingaNews, symbol) (track by Symbol object)
✅ Confirm subscription “activity” via OnData or self.history
✅ Write a heartbeat checker to log or alert on suspicious silences
✅ Implement defensive batching/rate-limiting in notify.telegram()
✅ Use an external microservice for translation/Telegram relay if needed
✅ Expect no platform-side status diagnostics/log of subscriptions in real-time

Let me know which area you want technical code snippets or deeper guidance on!

Sources: Benzinga News Feed - QuantConnect.com, Tiingo News Feed - QuantConnect.com

SIGN IN

Radically Open-Source Algorithmic Trading Engine

Join Our Discord Channel

Draft Discussions

Bookmarked Discussions

SEARCH DISCUSSIONS

TOP 5 Research Publications

444,200 Quants.

VOTE FOR UPCOMING FEATURES

Help mia

1. News Subscription Verification

Q1.1 – Q1.3: Subscription Confirmation, Verification, and Status APIs

Q1.4: News Silence

Q1.5: Logs/Diagnostics

2. News Data Coverage and Limitations

Q2.1: Maximum Subscriptions, Rate Limits

Q2.2: Benzinga Dataset Coverage

Q2.3: What Happens on Uncovered Stock?

3. Translation and Internationalization

Q3.1–Q3.2: Built-In and Available Translation Methods

Q3.3–Q3.4: External APIs, Networking/Latency

4. Telegram Integration Best Practices

Q4.1 – Q4.4

5. BenzingaNews Object Structure

Q5.1: Attributes

Q5.2: symbols Attribute Type

Q5.3: Categories/Tags Standardization

6. Implementation Review

Q6.1–Q6.2: Patterns

Q6.3: Set of Strings vs. Symbol Objects

Q6.4: Large Subscription Scaling Concerns

7. Error Handling and Reliability

Q7.1: Data Feed Failures/Downtime

Q7.2: Missed News (Restarts, Maintenance)

Q7.3: Health Check/Heartbeat

8. Testing and Debugging

Q8.1: Telegram/Backtesting

Q8.2: Simulating/Test News Articles

Q8.3: Debugging Missing Articles, Diagnostics

Summary Checklist for Production Readiness

Allocate to this Strategy

Organization

Team

Clone Strategy

Previous Ranking

IN THIS RESEARCH

PARTICIPANTS

Discussion Awards

SHARE RESEARCH

SHARE DISCUSSION

SHARE ARTICLE

SHARE

Actions

Join QuantConnect for Free

Q5.2: `symbols` Attribute Type